Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Johan's avatar
Feb 9Edited

Excellent points and a lot of fun thinking through.

You’ve identified something crucial that most freedom discourse misses: freedom is only meaningful when it reduces suffering and extends to everyone, especially the most vulnerable.

Your experiences show different dimensions of freedom, but from a behavioral perspective, true freedom is the capacity to be who you are and do what you want without causing direct or indirect harm to others, while being judged by the same standards that apply to everyone else.

Georgia gave you freedom from bureaucratic surveillance, Singapore showed financial freedom enables other freedoms, Mexico revealed freedom for human connection and purpose.

But here’s what’s missing in the general sense of freedom: these freedoms only existed for you because you had resources, mobility, and options most people don’t have. The Georgian landlord who trusted you? He can’t leave if the system fails him. The Singaporean experiencing “functional freedom” through wealth? That explicitly excludes those without resources. The neighbor in Oaxaca living that unhurried life? Probably doesn’t have the choice to optimize globally like you do.

Real freedom (which I agree is not in the United States) isn’t measured by how unconstrained the already-privileged feel. It’s measured by how the most vulnerable are treated. A society where you can disappear for six months without justification while others can’t access healthcare, afford housing, or exist without being targeted for their identity isn’t offering freedom. It’s offering selective liberty based on advantage.

Freedom that doesn’t apply universally, that doesn’t reduce suffering for everyone, isn’t freedom. It’s just a better class of cage that most people can’t afford to enter.​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​

Great articles and thank you for opening up these topics.

Andrew L Brodsky's avatar

I love this article and have done a lot of thinking about just this, including last year's trip to Georiga. I was particularly struck by the pro-European protesters in Tblisi.

All of this travel has given me an apprecation for the freedoms I still enjoy as an American ... but also how fragile it is and how important to protect it and exercise those freedoms

12 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?